On the peak of considerations over overseas interference in 2023, Canada’s spy company began including blanket warnings to assessments of overseas nationals looking for safety clearance to work for the federal authorities.
The Canadian Safety Intelligence Service (CSIS) began by warning federal departments about China’s nationwide safety legal guidelines, which permit Beijing to compel Chinese language nationals to supply the state with data.
The spy company expanded the warnings to incorporate an undisclosed variety of different nations, attaching the overall warnings to overseas nationals making use of to work in delicate positions with the federal authorities.
An unbiased federal assessment company is now warning that the observe dangers stereotyping overseas nationals and denying them federal work primarily based on their nation of origin — however CSIS says they’ll proceed to incorporate the “Non-Canadian Citizen Briefs” of their safety screening course of.
In a lately launched report, the Nationwide Safety and Intelligence Evaluate Company (NSIRA) warned that CSIS dangers biasing departments in opposition to clearing foreigners who pose no nationwide safety menace.
“Built-in into the individual’s safety evaluation, the transient shouldn’t be bespoke to the person. It accommodates threat-related details about the nation with the person’s citizenship being the one connection between the person and the nation,” the company wrote.
“No additional data or evaluation is included to tailor the data to the person safety screening applicant.”
Get every day Nationwide information
Get every day Canada information delivered to your inbox so you will by no means miss the day’s prime tales.
As of 2025, overseas nationals who aren’t Canadian residents are not eligible to acquire prime secret or enhanced prime secret clearance, NSIRA famous. So CSIS’s “Non-Canadian Citizen Briefs” are solely utilized to candidates for “secret” or “website entry” clearance.
Paul Champ, an Ottawa-based human rights and labour lawyer, has represented purchasers denied employment for failing to acquire safety clearance.
In a single ongoing case, Champ stated his shopper had labored for the UN, coping with extremely delicate materials for years, however International Affairs Canada denied his software for larger clearance.
Champ contends that was primarily based on his shopper’s nation of origin.
“I believe it’s a drawback. Canada, we’re positively a pluralistic society and democracy … however the actuality is, until you might be born right here, you’re at all times inherently suspect not directly in the case of employment with the federal authorities,” Champ stated in an interview Friday.
CSIS didn’t say what number of of these candidates had been cleared by the departments and companies finally liable for granting or denying safety clearance.
However the spy company disagreed with NSIRA’s warning, calling their country-specific warnings “fact-based details about nationwide safety dangers related to sure nations.”
“CSIS’ particular nation briefs are designed to mirror the present menace panorama, with out bias or discrimination, and are up to date repeatedly to make sure that they precisely seize evolving dangers and threats posed,” the company wrote in response.
“Safety assessments are only one part of sources of knowledge a authorities division could think about in its decision-making course of on a safety clearance software.”
The country-specific warnings began in 2023 with the Individuals’s Republic of China (PRC). Regardless of Prime Minister Mark Carney’s overtures to Beijing to enhance diplomatic and commerce relations, the PRC has lengthy been considered by the Canadian intelligence group because the nation’s largest nationwide safety menace.
That menace contains overseas interference and affect campaigns, financial espionage and extra conventional types of spying that will curiosity CSIS within the safety screening course of.
Underneath the PRC’s wide-reaching nationwide intelligence legal guidelines, Chinese language nationals will be induced to supply data to Beijing. The PRC has additionally been accused of leveraging family and friends nonetheless in China to coerce expats into working for the state.
However since 2023, CSIS has expanded the briefings to incorporate an undisclosed variety of different nations the place no related nationwide safety legal guidelines are cited, NSIRA famous.
“Whereas the transient states that the CSIS ‘has not recognized particular opposed or threat-related data concerning the topic,’ they proceed that the person ‘could also be liable to being induced to cooperate with a hostile overseas state in a means that constitutes a menace to the safety of Canada,’” NSIRA reported.
“The truth that a sure nation of origin could also be considered as suspect … that’s advantageous, we get that. But it surely simply signifies that (CSIS) must be considerate and deliberate when it comes to taking a look at different collateral sources (to evaluate) reliability,” Champ stated.
“In the event you don’t do this, you’re principally saying ‘we now have a discriminatory coverage.’”
© 2026 International Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
