Toronto’s struggling Finch West LRT seems to be utilizing an identical swap know-how to the one which crippled Ottawa’s mild rail system when it first launched, one thing a public inquiry warned different transit methods to not undertake.
Since opening firstly of a very chilly Toronto winter, the Finch West LRT has been beset by delays and repair disruptions recurrently tied to issues with the swap know-how embedded within the new transit line.
Switches are wanted on mild rail methods for trains to alter path. In harsh Canadian winters, they will turn out to be clogged with ice and snow, which must be melted for them to function and for the trains to run.
The Toronto system, like Ottawa earlier than it, is utilizing electrical heaters to soften ice and snow caught in its switching methods. The know-how proved so problematic in Ottawa it had to get replaced.
In Ottawa, the electrical heaters had been a daily downside, which a public inquiry mentioned had been accountable for “quite a few points on the road” when it opened.
In accordance with the inquiry, the choice to ultimately change these heaters with fuel confirmed that fuel was “more practical at heating the switches and stopping ice and snow build-up.”
The inquiry famous that, if Ottawa had been “extra aggressive within the number of swap heaters,” it could have “mitigated lots of the winter points upfront.”
Regardless of the difficulty in Ottawa and the findings of its inquiries, Finch launched with electrical heaters, which look like a part of its ongoing delays.
Get breaking Nationwide information
For information impacting Canada and world wide, join breaking information alerts delivered on to you after they occur.
Ontario Liberal MPP Stephen Blais, who beforehand sat on Ottawa metropolis council, accused the Ford authorities of failing to be taught the teachings of its personal public inquiry.
“The lead on Finch West, actually the top of Metrolinx, the transportation minister ought to have been totally conscious, and I might say have in-depth data of the report and the response to make sure these issues weren’t duplicated,” he informed International Information.
“Particularly with the electrical heaters as a result of it was such a small piece of know-how that created an unlimited downside on the system and delays on the system.”
Metrolinx CEO Michael Lindsay, nonetheless, insists the Finch West LRT is a distinct case than Ottawa. He mentioned the best way it has been designed to run alongside the busy street makes fuel heaters impractical.
“Perfecting the usage of heaters, together with the deployment of wayside workers to manually clear ice and snow is one thing which we proceed to work and concentrate on,” Lindsay wrote in a latest social media submit.
“Line 6 has a specific model of this problem, as a result of it interfaces with pedestrians and automobiles otherwise — operating because it does within the centre of Finch on predominantly embedded rails. This makes it unsuitable for the pure fuel heaters, that are current on another transit traces.”
A spokesperson for the Minister of Transportation agreed, saying Finch West’s embedded observe — somewhat than Ottawa’s grade-separated system — makes “natural-gas flame or hot-air swap heaters unsuitable.”
It’s unclear whether or not the Finch West LRT, which signed its building contract in 2018, might have made adjustments to accommodate completely different heating know-how.
Jonathan English, principal at Infrastory Insights, mentioned technological requirements and adjustments take time to return into impact, doubtless that means they wouldn’t have been prepared for Finch West’s designers or builders to pivot.
“My suspicion is lots of these designs have been finished a very long time in the past and sure issues don’t essentially get up to date straight away based mostly on new info when the designs have been set,” he mentioned.
“To some extent, each new mission goes to have its challenges. Nevertheless, this isn’t our first mission. We must always be taught classes from all the tasks that we’ve finished to this point. And its unlucky if we’re, actually, repeating errors.”
The newest outage for the Finch West LRT got here on Monday, with commuters compelled onto buses after a surge within the electrical energy for the swap heater blew a fuse.
A spokesperson for the Toronto Transit Fee mentioned the corporate contracted to construct and keep the route was nonetheless trying into the best way to stop the difficulty.
“Mosaic is constant to evaluate the basis trigger and are working to implement extra preventive measures to cut back the probability of comparable points sooner or later,” they mentioned.
© 2026 International Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
