Critics are questioning what downside the Alberta authorities’s transfer so as to add necessary citizenship markers to provincial identification goals to resolve, and say it opens the door to potential privateness breaches and discrimination.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith mentioned Monday the transfer is all about streamlining providers and stopping election fraud.
Zool Suleman, a Vancouver-based immigration lawyer, mentioned the United Conservative Occasion authorities’s impetus is unclear, and all Canadians ought to be apprehensive about an growing “creep” that forces the disclosure of extra private info.
“There’s some type of hovering worry which some persons are inflaming, which is that there are people who find themselves voting who will not be speculated to vote, or there are individuals accessing providers they’re not speculated to entry,” he mentioned in an interview.
“This sort of fomenting of worry is then remedied by having tighter and tighter identification necessities and exposing an increasing number of about who you’re on these identification paperwork,” he mentioned.
The change comes as Smith’s hand-picked Alberta Subsequent panel continues its tour of the province searching for assist for measures meant to push again towards federal insurance policies and applications. One proposal is for Alberta to create its personal provincial immigration system and withhold social providers from newcomers who aren’t authorized.
Suleman mentioned the federal government must be very cautious that the brand new rule doesn’t change into a strategy to goal newcomers or individuals with momentary standing.
Get breaking Nationwide information
For information impacting Canada and world wide, join breaking information alerts delivered on to you once they occur.
“We have already got identification to show when you’re a Canadian citizen. Tens of millions of Canadians have already got this identification. It’s referred to as a Canadian passport or a Canadian citizenship card or a delivery certificates in a Canadian province,” mentioned Suleman.
Whereas proof of citizenship, residency standing, and even refugee standing are usually accepted as half the applying course of for social applications in Alberta, non-Canadian residents, together with everlasting residents, wouldn’t have any new notation on their Alberta IDs.
Suleman apprehensive that when authorities get used to seeing Canadian citizenship standing on a doc like a driver’s licence, it may be utilized by different businesses to attempt to goal people who find themselves not Canadian residents.
“The absence of knowledge on a card turns into a way by which to profile individuals,” he mentioned.
Service Alberta Minister Dale Nally mentioned including citizenship markers to driver’s licences and different types of ID gained’t result in discrimination and can streamline the verification course of.
Laws is to be put ahead this fall to make the modifications, which the federal government mentioned would come into impact subsequent 12 months.
Diane McLeod, Alberta’s Data and Privateness Commissioner, mentioned in a press release Tuesday her workplace would want to see the specifics to evaluate whether or not the laws aligns with current privateness legislation.
“It’s unclear from the federal government announcement as to what goal the inclusion of this info on Albertans’ driver’s licenses will serve. It’s additionally unclear what the profit for Albertans can be,” McLeod wrote.
She added that citizenship will be delicate info, so the federal government would want to indicate how any good thing about placing it on a driver’s license would outweigh the privateness dangers.
Opposition NDP immigration critic Lizette Tejada has mentioned the UCP authorities has not been capable of present readability on why the change is important.
Elections Alberta confirmed Monday that it issued three reprimands associated to ineligible voting for the reason that final provincial election in 2023.
Alberta well being card numbers are additionally to be added to drivers’ licences.
Smith mentioned the province has registered simply over 530,000 extra Alberta well being care numbers than there are individuals within the province and including the numbers to drivers’ licences ought to assist decide that are “outliers.”
Well being officers say a number of the discrepancy in numbers could also be defined by people who’ve moved to different provinces or territories however haven’t but cancelled their Alberta protection, or by Albertans who’ve handed away exterior the province with out the division being notified.
It has additionally mentioned there may be some proof, based mostly on medical claims, that some former residents proceed to make use of their Alberta well being playing cards.
© 2025 The Canadian Press
